Discussions: Is Christianity the Only Way to God? (part 1)
“I am the Way, the Truth, and the Light. No one comes to the Father but through me.”
A few weeks ago I was at home minding my own business when I received a text message from one of my best friends, Mr. Winfred Burns.
It read…
“Check out my FB conversation, I’m sure you will enjoy it”
I can almost imagine an evil laugh coming from Winfred as he clicked send on that ole’ Blackberry Storm of his!
When I logged on to check out this intriguing “conversation” it turned out that Big Win had managed to stir up quite a firestorm of activity, something like 24 comments when I first checked it…
“Today’s conversation. Though we all are different and have different beliefs in some major areas why can we not have a place of worship where all people can come. I don’t mean just blacks and whites but Muslims, Christians, Jehovah’s Witnesses etc. Doesn’t our love and unity allow that? Let’s talk…”
Part of me was thrilled at the thought of discussing this topic and part of me swallowed hard and thought to myself…
“What did your Big Brother just suck you into?”
The claim that Jesus is the only (some would use the term exclusive) way to God is central to the Christian faith! According to traditional Christianity there can be no two ways about it, without believing in Jesus there is no salvation.
At the same time what Christian with half a heart has never asked themselves about the millions of people throughout the ages of time who have never heard so much as the whisper of his name? Or the God-fearing Muslims and Jews to whom the concept of monotheism is taken with such seriousness and reverence, that to make the claim that God was a man, or that he had a Son, is the highest form of blasphemy? Can we blame the ignorant for their ignorance, can we blame the reverent for grasping to tightly to the commands of their God? Is that fair? Is that Just?
The discussion Winfred started dealt with this issue head on and as it began to unfurl responders were divided into two camps: The “all religions teach the same thing” camp, and the “traditional Christian” camp.
The traditional Christian camp was lead by a guy named Dan and he knew his stuff…
“…I think this is why it is so critical to have a grasp of what you believe. For instance what make Christianity Christian? And at what point, even from an evolutionary standpoint (because evolution is fundamentally different than progress) does it cease to be Christian. I do not fear progression. If Paul would have feared it from the Jews, the faith we hold so dear today would not even exist. But I think it’s important that we understand what are the fundamental elements that make up our faith and how from an historical perspective we arrived at a universal understanding of what constitutes Christianity. I think it’s difficult to stand in the face of over 2000 years of Christian history and simply say, this is how we’re going to do it now, we’re changing the game. Because even Christianity’s evolutionary process from Judaism that was not done, and Kelleigh if I am reading you wrong, please let me know I think the bible is clear that good deeds alone are not enough, but its believing in his Son that is the critical issue.”
I sensed a challenge. I had to respond.
“Great discussion Win!
Dan I appreciate the difficulties you are raising regarding the place of exclusivity in the practice of historical Christianity. I think they highlight the importance of careful consideration on topics like these!
I have a few thoughts and I’ll try to keep them concise…
I believe that Christianity as a faith stretches back to the beginning of time and that it has been practiced by men, angels, and who knows what other beings, since before the world began. In fact considering it’s ancient origins I would say the last 2000 years are, in comparison, but the blink of an eye.
Considering it’s ancient roots Christianity has been practiced in a multitude of forms…even if we only accept the Christian Traditions! In recorded history alone we have it in the form practiced by Adam and Eve before the fall, by mankind from the fall to the times of Abraham, by the descendants of Abraham to the revelation of the law of Moses, by the Jews from Moses to the birth of Christ…and on and on!
All of these traditions, Christians believe, attained a right relationship and connection with God. My first question is how? Did the rules change with each step along the way? Or was Jesus the key to a right relationship with God from the very beginning?
John 1 tells us that “The Word” existed from the very beginning in a form other than flesh…and that in recent times “The Word” put on flesh in the historical person of Jesus. What Christians often don’t consider is that since He existed in a form other than flesh, He was worshipped in a form other than flesh.
This idea has, I think, some startling implications.
Jesus was very clear that He is the only way to salvation and that we must believe in Him to have right standing with God. The central revelation of Christianity is that there is nothing we can do to save ourselves, that we can only attain communion with God through Christ.
The message of Christianity is then…”God as our Rescuer!”
My next question is then “What does it mean to believe in Jesus?” and “In what form must we believe in Him?”
I don’t have the answer but I don’t think I take too much liberty in proposing that what is required for Salvation is not belief in the physical, historical, person of Jesus of Nazareth but that we, as were the saints and disciples of old are redeemed by faith in “The Word of God” or to put it another way faith in “God as our Rescuer!” The essence of who Jesus is.
Do I think that heaven is filled with idol worshippers? No. But I think that those who truly put their fate in the hands of God and, thus their faith in Christ, are spread across religions and certainly include select Jews, Muslims, Jehovah’s Witnesses and many other faiths and traditions!
We may disagree in the details and terms of religious expression. We may think that each other are in error in our understanding of God. But let’s face it, when you consider how different the worship of God has looked throughout the entire history of creation, these differences are inconsequential. If you think that angels do not shake their heads at the incomplete nature of our concept of who God is and at our meager understanding of how true spirituality works then you have your nose pressed to the canvas and have lost sight of the big picture.
Christianity is, like any other religion, a response to the revelation of God and an attempt to understand what life means. Religions may be somewhat closer or farther from true spirituality in their doctrines and ideas. They may be more or less useful in our interactions with each other as humans and in the richness of life they produce in the follower. But one thing is certain, many individuals throughout history have made idols out of them somehow believing they have captured and articulated the eternal in a system of beliefs and practices. Nothing could be further from the truth. These things are but tools to help us along the way. Some may use the stars, some a map, some a compass but all true God lovers are on the same journey.
Let me be clear here. I am not embracing relativism and denying the exclusivity of Jesus as the only means to salvation. I am merely attempting to more properly articulate what that exclusivity really entails, and who, when all is said and done, Jesus really is.
My position is that there will be no idol worshippers in heaven! Be those idols: statues, money, fame, ourselves, or even Christian theology and doctrine.
We are saved, according to my view, by the gift of God as we put our faith completely in Him as our Rescuer!
The Bible tells us that of all the things we hold dear in this world, three things are timeless components of original spirituality…faith, hope, and love!
The rest is simply details, more a way for us to co-exist in this life, then to receive salvation or worship God.”
(The End)
(This blog is intended to encourage discussion and dialogue on what this writer considers one of life’s most important components…Spirituality! It is an attempt for me to gain a better understanding of what my personal views on the exclusivity of Christ and Salvation are by putting them out there for fellow seekers to critique, challenge, and interact with.
If you would like to participate in the conversation feel free to email me…
ethic3@gmail.com)
(Notes & References)
In this blog I realize that I may be introducing a few ideas that are not familiar to traditional Christians. In order to provide a scriptural basis for some of these arguments I have prepared this section…
Idea: Jesus existed in some form other than flesh and was worshipped in this form.
“The Good News is about his Son. In his earthly life he was born into King David’s family line, and he was shown to be the Son of God when he was raised from the dead by the power of the Holy Spirit. He is Jesus Christ our Lord.”
(Romans 1:3-4)
Commentary: The essence of the Son was not his earthly life as Jesus of Nazareth. His essence or identity predated his humanity rather than being derived from it, it was in fact, obscured by it. Thus I would argue that just as it is possible to believe in the humanity of Jesus but deny his true pre-existent identity, it is also to believe in the identity and work of Jesus while being ignorant of, or mistrusting of the historical person of Jesus.
Idea 2: The Old Testament saints were redeemed as we are, by faith in Jesus.
“For the Scriptures tell us, ‘Abraham believed God and God counted him as righteous because of his faith.’
When people work, their wages are not a gift, but something they have earned. But people are counted as righteous, not because of their work, but because of their faith in God who forgives sinners.”
(Romans 4:3-5)
Commentary: This faith wasn’t merely that Abraham would have a son or that he would be the father of many nations but that God would redeem mankind by his own hand.
In fact Jesus himself says…
” ‘Your father Abraham rejoiced as he looked forward to my coming. He saw it and was glad.’
The people said, ‘You aren’t even fifty years old. How can you say you’ve seen Abraham?’ Jesus answered, “I tell you the truth, before Abraham was even born, I AM!’”
(John 8:56-58)
Should we believe that when Abraham looked forward to his coming that he had a crystal clear picture in his head that a man would be born named Jesus, that he would be crucified, and raised from the dead on the third day? It, of course, is a possibility, though personally I think it would be a little unusual for a man who took his wife’s servant into his bed in order to fulfill God’s promise of a son, to have such a vivid picture of the future in regards to the salvation of the human race. I instead think it is ten times more reasonable to believe that Abraham held to a notion that God loved humanity and that God was going to rescue mankind from sin. He may not have known how, or understood the role he would play in that rescue, but as sure as he was alive he believed it would come to pass. When Abraham contemplated his own salvation, in his mind, his only hope was the “Promise’.
Paul expounds in Romans and draws the correlation to our own faith…
“So the promise is received by faith. It is given as a free gift. And we are all certain to receive it, whether or not we obey the law of Moses, if we have faith like Abraham’s.”
(Romans 4:16)
Should this come as such a surprise to us? Is not precedent set in scripture again and again of the heart over the physical appearance, of the spiritual over the material, of essence over ritual…
“But the time is coming-indeed it’s here now-when true worshipers will worship the Father in spirit and in truth. The Father is looking for those to worship him that way. For God is Spirit, so those who worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth.”
(John 4:23-24)
“You do not desire a sacrifice, or I would offer one…The sacrifice you desire is a broken spirit.”
(Psalms 51:16-17) a psalm of David
“‘I have found David son of Jesse, a man after my own heart.’”
(Acts 13:22)
“The Sabbath was made to meet the needs of the people, and not people to meet the requirements of the Sabbath.”
(Mark 2:27)
posted on 14.04.10